The Other Side Isn't Who Your Feed Says It Is
By Wade MacCallum, Rogue Management
Spend an evening on social media and you could come away convinced Canada is splitting down the middle. Spend it at a hockey rink or a kitchen table and you'd meet a different country. I've worked in the gap between those two pictures for years, and I've come to think the gap is the real story: most Canadians are far less divided than their feeds suggest, and the distance between what people believe and what they see online is starting to do damage of its own.
A quick word on terms. People often mix up conservative, the outlook, with the parties that carry the name. The federal Conservatives and the provincial Progressive Conservatives differ in what they believe, and PCs tend to describe themselves as socially progressive and fiscally conservative. Progressive, meanwhile, usually gets read as Liberal, and perhaps more so as NDP or Green.
As an outlook, conservative usually means a smaller, leaner government, lower taxes, a strong economy and resource sector, personal responsibility, and respect for tradition and institutions. Progressive usually means a more active government, stronger social programs, faster action on climate and equity, and a readiness to change institutions to get there. Most Canadians hold a mix of both, and neither one maps neatly onto American Republicans or Democrats.
I'll lean on American research at points, because there's far more of it and it shows where things can go, and I'll flag it when I do. America's parties are their own creatures, and ours aren't branch offices of anyone else's.
Less divided than we think
Start with friendship. When University of Toronto political scientist Eric Merkley asked partisan Canadians how they'd feel about a close friend who backed the other party, about 22% said they'd be uncomfortable. That means nearly four in five are fine with it. In the United States, 43% say they wouldn't even date someone on the other side of the Trump question, which shows how far a country can drift.
Violence follows the same pattern, with one warning attached. A national survey last fall by the Canadian Digital Media Research Network asked Canadians how justified it would be for people who share their own political views to use violence. The average answer was 0.8 out of ten. On the whole, this is a country that wants nothing to do with it.
Asked how justified violence would be from people on their own side, Canadians answered 0.8 out of 10.
The number that should worry us
The warning is in the abstract question. In that same research, 21% of Canadians said political violence is sometimes necessary for social change. Among Canadians aged 18 to 34 the figure was 33%, up from 26% a year earlier. These are young people who mostly reject violence by their own side, yet a third have come to believe it's sometimes how change happens. I don't think you get there from the kitchen table. You get there from a steady diet of content telling you the other side is dangerous and the normal channels don't work.
One in three Canadians aged 18 to 34 now says political violence is sometimes necessary for social change, up from about one in four a year earlier.
The same research points to a mechanism. Canadians overestimate how much their political opponents support violence, often by double or more, and the people with the most exaggerated picture of the other side were two to three times more supportive of violence themselves.
Shouting down, and the silence it leaves
Much of that distorted picture comes down to who speaks up online. During the last federal campaign, the Media Ecosystem Observatory found that about half of Canadians were comfortable sharing political views at work or school, but only a little more than a third were comfortable doing it online. As the researchers put it, political content on social media "is likely to disproportionately come from and reflect the views of the minority of Canadians who feel comfortable sharing their opinions in online spaces."

Shouting down is real, and it's powerful. A 2022 Macdonald-Laurier Institute survey of more than a thousand Canadian professors found that 57% of right-leaning faculty had self-censored for fear of the consequences, against 34% of professors overall. American polling points the same way, with conservatives there far more likely than strong liberals to say they hold back.
57% of right-leaning Canadian professors have self-censored for fear of the consequences, against 34% of professors overall.
Anyone who has watched a reasonable comment get buried under a pile-on knows the lesson bystanders take from it, and it isn't to argue back. They stop posting.
Organized, or just unopposed
This is where the left's organizing lead comes in, and I want to be precise about it. Some of it is real and deliberate. In the United States, the Democratic fundraising platform ActBlue processed more than $3.8 billion in the 2024 cycle, more than double its Republican counterpart, and groups like Indivisible have built networks that stay switched on year-round. Here at home, Progress Toronto showed what a patient, well-connected advocacy group can do in a city. Those were built on purpose.
But a lot of what looks like organization is something else. When one side goes quiet because it's tired of being shouted down, the side still talking looks bigger and more unified than it is. The platforms then amplify what travels. One American study of nearly three million posts from news outlets and members of Congress found that each word attacking the political out-group raised the odds of a post being shared by 67%.
In one American study, each word attacking the political out-group raised the odds of a post being shared by 67%.
Put real organization, the other side's self-censorship and an engagement system that pays for contempt together, and you get a feed that looks like everyone agrees. No single study proves that whole chain, but each link has evidence behind it, and I think it holds.
None of this needs a rigged algorithm to explain it. Twitter's own researchers found its algorithm amplified Canada's Conservative MPs more than Liberal ones. What the record does show is clumsy overreach and outside pressure. In 2024 Mark Zuckerberg told the U.S. Congress that the American administration had "repeatedly pressured our teams for months to censor certain COVID-19 content," and that he regretted not being more outspoken. A few months later Meta scrapped its American fact-checking program, conceding that "a program intended to inform too often became a tool to censor." Heavy-handed moderation teaches people the same thing a pile-on does, which is to keep their heads down.
What a distorted picture costs
When the loudest and best-organized voices become the picture of what the country thinks, the people who disagree feel more alone than they are and say even less, while everyone else judges the other side by its most extreme online version. That's how ordinary disagreement turns into fear. Simply popping the bubble doesn't fix it; researchers working with Meta cut people's exposure to like-minded content and saw almost no change.
A Stanford-led study that pushed hostile posts lower in people's X feeds, on the other hand, warmed them toward the other side by about as much as three years of normal opinion change. What gets rewarded matters more than who's in the room.
Show up, every day, everywhere
If the quiet majority stays quiet, the loudest and best-organized network will keep defining it. The answer is presence: showing up continuously and honestly, in the places people actually spend their time, with the label still on it, and staying there long after any campaign has wrapped up. It means saying the reasonable thing in public even when it earns some angry replies, because the people reading silently need to see someone say it. And it means organizations of every stripe building networks that last instead of switching them on once every few years.
At Rogue we spend a lot of time listening to what's really being said online, and the gap between the loud version and the real one is almost always wider than people expect. Closing it is slow, unglamorous, permanent work, and it belongs to everyone who wants Canadians to see each other as they actually are.




Comments